If we are taking a player and keeping him for 10 years, I take Heyward.

Taking a player for the right now, I take Berkman. But at the same time, if Berkman is on a different team and not surrounded by the bats of Pujols and Holliday, I don't think he produces like he is this season. But with that said, I take Jay Bruce over either! But I'm biased as well.